The Carter House, Summit’s Historical Society Headquarters

Patricia Meola, President of the Summit Historical Society, gave a report on the history of the Carter House and the society at the Common Council Meeting on November 16, 2026.

Patricia Meola, President of the Summit Historical Society.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LwXi0GsZdmY&t=32m44s

Among the items on council’s agenda is a vote to renew the ground lease for the Historical Society’s headquarters, the Carter House, at 90 Butler Parkway, so we thought we would offer a short recap of who we are, what we do, and what we have at The Carter House Museum, which dates to 1741 and is the oldest remaining building in town.

In the 1980s, the house stood on River Road, where it had been a private family home since long before George Washington marched troops to Morristown during the Revolutionary War along what is today’s Route 24. In 1986, though, Summit resident Glen Johnson, the founder of Aircast, bought the site with plans to demolish it and construct his company’s headquarters. Alarmed that the city would lose such a historic structure, historical society volunteers began fundraising to relocate the house and its barn to city-owned, rented land on Butler Parkway, about a quarter-mile away.

Fast forward to today. The house is a treasured community resource where the archives are available to all, at no charge. We are 100% volunteer, and take quite seriously our responsibility as stewards of the society and caretakers of the Carter House and its contents, which we hope remain on Butler Parkway for the next 100 years - and beyond. On our shelves and in our files, you will find maps, postcards, obituaries, family histories, more than 100 years of Summit High yearbooks, scrapbooks, dozens of cookbooks with Summit connections, city directories and copies of the 1989 city-wide historic sites survey.

In addition, we have a period oil portrait of Jonathan Crane Bonnel, who in the 1830s offered a land easement to the Morris & Essex Railway that allowed trains to come up and over what was called “the summit of the short hills” to the area that is now our downtown. We have a painting in our library by Hudson River School artist Worthington Whittredge, who resided on Summit Avenue for decades. We have the Congressional Medal of Honor received posthumously by a Summit soldier for his actions during World War I.

Our visitors include everyone from published authors and academic researchers to local residents simply curious about when a particular home was built. In addition to houses, people look up schools, hosts of worship, streets, ancestors and local businesses and industries. Summit High students come to research the Historical Minutes they present from this very podium. Members of the city's planning and zoning boards also make use of our files.

Our newest community partnership is one with the school districts history and social studies teachers in grades 6 through 12, who visited the Carter House as part of a recent professional development day. Our joint efforts with the Summit Historic Preservation Commission date back to its founding as a committee. Our board often donates prizes for fundraisers hosted by local schools and non-profits. Our relationship with the Summit Free Public Library is extensive. We have both presented and sponsored slide lectures at the library, and we joined forces to obtain a grant that funded digitization of Summit High yearbooks. We have partnered on projects with HomeTowne Television, and an intern at that channel is currently editing a short documentary that focuses upon the Carter House. We frequently work with Union County, our largest and most visible collaboration being the annual Four Centuries open house weekend each October.

Maybe you know of a group - a book club, a Scout troop, a gathering of alumns — who might like to use the Carter House as a destination. Reach out to us, and we'll work with you to make it happen. Look for the gorgeous historic marker on our front lawn on Butler Parkway, and you’ll know you're in the right place.